Judge denies motion to bring outside jury for Mountain City murder trial

10:58 am | January 8, 2014

JONESBOROUGH – Although he said he was “sensitive” to the amount of media coverage an upcoming murder trial has received, Judge Jon Kerry Blackwood ruled against a request to bring in a jury from outside the local coverage area.

On Wednesday morning, in the George Jaynes Justice Center, Blackwood denied a motion for a change of venire made by attorneys for Jamie Curd and Barbara and Jenelle Potter, who have each been charged with first-degree murder for the January 2012 deaths of Mountain City residents Billy Clay Payne and Billie Jean Hayworth.

On Oct. 29, Blackwood approved a motion for joinder, which combined all three defendants’ cases into one trial. That same day, Blackwood also sentenced Marvin Potter – Barbara Potter’s husband and Jenelle Potter’s father – to consecutive life sentences after he was convicted on two first-degree murder charges, one for Payne and the other for Hayworth.

Because of the media coverage Marvin Potter’s trial received, attorneys Randy Fallin, Cameron Hyder, and Casey Sears – who are representing Barbara Potter, Jenelle Potter, and Curd, respectively – each expressed their concerns that an impartial jury would not be found in Washington County.

“The whole foundation of a fair trial would be an impartial jury,” Fallin said. “What we would like to do – and I’m sure the court would, too – is to ensure a fair hearing for these folks from a jury panel that doesn’t come in here with a lot of preconceived notions and/or exposure to information that may or may not be accurate.”

For the complete story, look for it in Thursday’s edition of the Star.

Elizabethton Star back open navigation

Switch to our desktop site